Rotator cuff tear: symptoms, a management plan, and when surgery helps

- The rotator cuff is a group of four muscles and their tendons that hold the ball of the shoulder centred in the socket and power lifting and rotating the arm.
- Tears range from small partial thickness tears to large full thickness tears where the tendon has come away from the bone.
- Not every tear needs surgery. Many, particularly partial tears with milder symptoms, are managed well with physiotherapy and changes to how the shoulder is used.
- A full thickness tear does not grow back to the bone on its own. Whether that matters depends on your age, your symptoms and how much the shoulder limits you.
- A sudden loss of strength after a fall or injury in an active person is worth assessing early, because a fresh tear is usually easier to repair than one that has been left for a long time. See rotator cuff repair.
Common symptoms
- Shoulder pain, often spreading down the outer upper arm
- Pain at night and when lying on the affected side
- Weakness lifting the arm in front or out to the side
- Difficulty reaching overhead or behind your back
Treatment without surgery
- Physiotherapy to strengthen the rotator cuff and shoulder blade muscles
- Adjusting aggravating activities
- Simple pain relief
- Anti-inflammatory medication, if your GP agrees it is safe for you
When surgery is considered
- A full thickness tear from an injury in an active person, particularly under 60
- A large tear with significant weakness
- A partial tear not improving after 3 to 6 months of treatment
- A tear that significantly limits daily activities or sport
What the rotator cuff does
The rotator cuff is made up of four muscles and their tendons: supraspinatus, infraspinatus, teres minor and subscapularis. Together they surround the shoulder joint, keep the ball (the top of the arm bone) centred in the shallow socket, and power the shoulder through rotation and lifting.
How tears happen
Tears happen in two main ways.
- Injury. A fall, a heavy lift or a sudden pull on the arm can tear a tendon that was previously healthy.
- Wear over time. Tendons can thin and tear gradually with age and repeated loading. Many people with this kind of tear never had a single injury they can point to.
Tears are described by how deep they go. A partial thickness tear involves only part of the tendon. A full thickness tear goes right through, and the tendon may be partly or completely detached from the bone.
How it is diagnosed
Diagnosis starts with your history and an examination of shoulder movement and rotator cuff strength, including a check of the neck, which can also cause arm pain. X-rays show the bones and joint. An ultrasound or MRI shows the tendons and whether a tear is partial or full thickness.
A tear seen on a scan is not, by itself, a reason for surgery. Tears become more common with age and many people with one have few or no symptoms. The decision is based on your symptoms, your examination and what you need the shoulder to do.
Your management plan
For most tears that are not a fresh injury in an active person, the first approach is non-surgical. The aim is to settle pain and build up the muscles around the shoulder so they share the load.
1. Settle the pain
Change how you do the tasks that aggravate it: keep heavy items at waist height and avoid repeated overhead lifting. Use simple pain relief, and anti-inflammatory medication if your GP agrees it is safe for you, particularly if you have stomach, kidney or heart problems or take blood thinners.
2. Restore movement
A physiotherapist will guide gentle exercises to keep the shoulder moving and stop it stiffening.
3. Strengthen
Progressive strengthening of the rotator cuff and the muscles around the shoulder blade takes load off the torn tendon and helps the shoulder work more efficiently.
4. Review
Partial tears can improve significantly with physiotherapy and time. If a partial tear has not improved after at least 3 to 6 months of this programme, surgery is worth discussing.
When to be seen sooner
Ask for an earlier review if you lose the ability to lift your arm after a fall or injury, or if pain and weakness are getting worse despite the programme.
When surgery is considered
Surgery is generally recommended for:
- An acute full thickness tear in an active patient, particularly under 60
- A large or massive tear with significant weakness
- A partial tear that has not improved after at least 3 to 6 months of non-surgical treatment
- A tear that significantly limits daily activities or sport
Surgery repairs the tendon back onto the bone through keyhole incisions, using anchors and strong sutures. A sling is worn for six weeks afterwards, and full strength after a large repair can take up to 12 months. The rotator cuff repair page explains the operation and recovery in detail.
Large, long-standing tears
Very large tears that have been present for a long time may pull back and the muscle may turn fatty, so the tendon cannot always be fully repaired. Options then include a partial repair, a tendon transfer, or a joint replacement. Over time, a large unrepaired tear can lead to a form of shoulder arthritis called rotator cuff tear arthropathy, where the ball rides up and wears against the top of the socket. A reverse shoulder replacement is designed for this, because it lets the deltoid muscle lift the arm without relying on the rotator cuff.
Taking the next step
If shoulder pain or weakness is affecting your sleep or everyday activities, a GP referral for specialist assessment is a reasonable next step. Bring any X-rays, ultrasound or MRI scans you have had, and a list of the treatments you have tried. Dr Mooney consults at Eastwood, Tea Tree Gully (North East Health Centre), Woodville, Naracoorte and Mount Gambier.
Common questions
Can a rotator cuff tear heal on its own?
Partial thickness tears in some patients improve significantly with physiotherapy and time. Full thickness tears do not heal on their own, because the tendon does not grow back to the bone. If surgery is recommended, it is to repair that defect.
Does every rotator cuff tear need surgery?
No. Many tears, particularly partial tears with milder symptoms, are managed well with physiotherapy and changes to activity. Surgery is considered for tears from an injury in active people, large tears with weakness, and tears that have not improved with a proper course of non-surgical treatment.
How long should I try physiotherapy before considering surgery?
For a partial tear, at least 3 to 6 months of non-surgical treatment is usual before surgery is considered. A fresh full thickness tear from an injury in an active person is different and is worth assessing early.
What happens if I leave a large tear?
Very large, long-standing tears can pull back and become harder or impossible to repair, and some go on to develop rotator cuff tear arthropathy. That is not inevitable, and the right choice depends on your symptoms and needs.
How long is recovery after rotator cuff repair?
A sling is worn for six weeks. Most patients return to most activities by four to six months, return to sport is around six months depending on the sport and the repair, and full healing after a large repair can take up to 12 months.
Related reading
Before your appointment
Preparing for your first orthopaedic consultation →Why surgery has a gap →Choosing an orthopaedic surgeon in Adelaide →Related conditions and procedures
Rotator cuff repair →Reverse shoulder replacement →Shoulder arthritis →Shoulder stabilisation →Discuss your rotator cuff with Dr Mooney
A specialist consultation gives you a clear picture of what is happening in your shoulder and what your options are. A GP referral is required for Medicare rebate purposes.
The information in this article is provided for general educational purposes and does not constitute medical advice. Individual circumstances vary. Please consult Dr Mooney or your GP to discuss your specific situation.