Shoulder arthritis: symptoms, treatment without surgery, and when to consider replacement

- Shoulder arthritis is wear of the cartilage in the shoulder’s ball-and-socket joint, causing pain, stiffness and loss of movement.
- The pain is usually felt deep in the shoulder and down the outer upper arm, and is often worse at night.
- For most people the first approach is non-surgical: physiotherapy, adjusting aggravating activities, and simple pain relief.
- Many people with shoulder arthritis also have a torn or worn rotator cuff, which is why a reverse shoulder replacement is often the operation of choice.
- When pain and night pain continue despite non-surgical treatment, reverse shoulder replacement is worth discussing. Dr Mooney plans every shoulder replacement in 3D from a CT scan.
Shoulder pain is common, and most of it is not arthritis. But pain that builds over months or years, wakes you at night, and slowly takes away your ability to reach, dress or lift is often a sign that the joint itself is wearing out.
Shoulder arthritis is more common after 60, after a previous shoulder injury, and in people who have had a large rotator cuff tear. Understanding what is happening in the joint helps you make sense of the treatment options, from physiotherapy through to shoulder replacement.
Common symptoms
- Deep shoulder pain
- Night pain
- Stiffness and loss of reach
- Grinding or clicking
- Weakness lifting the arm
Treatment without surgery
- Physiotherapy and exercise
- Adjusting aggravating activities
- Simple pain relief
- Anti-inflammatory medication, if safe for you
When surgery is considered
- Pain disturbing sleep most nights
- Everyday tasks becoming difficult
- Non-surgical treatment no longer helping
- Advanced changes on X-ray
What is shoulder arthritis?
The main shoulder joint (the glenohumeral joint) is a ball-and-socket joint. The ball is the top of the arm bone (the humerus) and the socket (the glenoid) is a shallow cup on the shoulder blade. Both surfaces are covered in smooth cartilage, and the rotator cuff tendons hold the ball centred in the socket as the arm moves.
In arthritis, that cartilage gradually wears away. The joint surfaces become rough, the joint can lose its normal shape, and the shoulder becomes painful and stiff. There are several common causes:
- Osteoarthritis. Gradual wear of the cartilage, usually over many years.
- Rotator cuff tear arthropathy. Arthritis that develops after a large, long-standing rotator cuff tear. Without the cuff holding it centred, the ball rides up and wears against the top of the socket.
- Arthritis after injury. A previous fracture or dislocation can damage the joint surface and lead to arthritis years later.
- Inflammatory arthritis. Conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis can affect the shoulder.
Pain on the very top of the shoulder, at the end of the collarbone, is usually a different joint (the acromioclavicular joint) and is assessed separately.
Shoulder arthritis symptoms
Deep shoulder pain
The pain is usually felt deep inside the shoulder and often spreads down the outer part of the upper arm. It tends to be worse with use and settles somewhat with rest in the earlier stages.
Night pain
Pain at night is one of the most troublesome symptoms. Many people cannot lie on the affected side and wake when they roll over.
Stiffness and loss of reach
As arthritis progresses the shoulder loses movement, particularly rotation. Reaching behind your back, doing up a bra, tucking in a shirt, washing your hair or reaching a high shelf all become harder.
Grinding and clicking
A grinding or catching feeling as the shoulder moves is common as the joint surfaces become rough.
Weakness
When the rotator cuff is also torn, lifting the arm in front of you or out to the side can become weak, and some people can no longer raise the arm above shoulder height.
Risk factors
- Age. Shoulder arthritis becomes more common after 60.
- A large rotator cuff tear. A long-standing, large rotator cuff tear can lead to rotator cuff tear arthropathy.
- Previous injury. Fractures around the shoulder and repeated dislocations increase the long-term risk.
- Previous shoulder surgery. Some earlier operations, particularly for instability, are associated with arthritis later.
- Inflammatory arthritis. Rheumatoid arthritis and related conditions can affect the joint.
- Family history. Osteoarthritis tends to run in families.
Seeing a shoulder specialist in Adelaide
Dr Mooney consults at Eastwood, Tea Tree Gully (North East Health Centre), Woodville, Naracoorte and Mount Gambier.
At a first consultation for shoulder arthritis, Dr Mooney will typically:
- Take a detailed history of your symptoms, what makes them better or worse, and what you would like to be able to do
- Examine the shoulder: range of movement, strength of the rotator cuff, and the neck, which can also cause arm pain
- Review X-rays of the shoulder, and arrange a CT scan, ultrasound or MRI if more detail is needed about the joint or the rotator cuff
- Explain what the imaging shows and how advanced the arthritis is
- Agree a plan with you: continuing non-surgical treatment, or discussing surgery if that is the better option
There is no obligation to proceed with surgery at or after a consultation.
Shoulder arthritis treatment without surgery
For most people with shoulder arthritis, the first approach is non-surgical. These treatments do not reverse the arthritis, but they can reduce pain and keep the shoulder working for a long time.
Physiotherapy and exercise
A physiotherapist can help keep the shoulder moving and strengthen the rotator cuff and the muscles around the shoulder blade, which take load off the joint and help the shoulder work more efficiently.
Adjusting activities
Changing how you do aggravating tasks, such as keeping heavy items at waist height and avoiding repeated overhead lifting, can reduce flare-ups.
Pain relief
Simple pain relief and anti-inflammatory medication can help manage pain. Check with your GP that these are safe for you, particularly if you have stomach, kidney or heart problems or take blood thinners.
When surgery is considered
Non-surgical treatment is the right starting point, but it has limits. Surgery is worth discussing when:
- Pain disturbs your sleep most nights
- Everyday tasks such as dressing, washing your hair or reaching a shelf have become difficult
- Non-surgical treatment no longer gives enough relief
- X-rays show advanced arthritis
There is no fixed rule about when to have a shoulder replacement. The decision is based on your symptoms, how much the shoulder limits your life, and what the imaging shows.
Surgical options
Dr Mooney performs reverse total shoulder replacement. In a reverse replacement the ball and socket are swapped around: a metal ball is fixed to the socket side and a cup to the top of the arm bone. This lets the deltoid muscle lift the arm even when the rotator cuff is torn or worn, which is why it is so often used for shoulder arthritis and for rotator cuff tear arthropathy. It is also used for primary arthritis where the socket has worn unevenly or is tilted backwards (retroversion), with an angled baseplate or glenosphere used to correct the shape of the socket.
Every shoulder replacement is planned from a CT scan, which builds a 3D model of your joint. At Eastwood Private Hospital the plan is delivered with the Stryker Mako robotic system, which Eastwood first used for a shoulder replacement in October 2026. At Calvary Adelaide Hospital the operation is performed to the same CT-based plan.
If a different operation would suit your shoulder better, Dr Mooney will explain why and arrange the right referral.
Taking the next step
If shoulder pain is affecting your sleep or everyday activities, a GP referral for specialist assessment is a reasonable next step. Bring any X-rays or scans you have had, and a list of the treatments you have tried.
Common questions
Where is shoulder arthritis pain felt?
Shoulder arthritis pain is usually felt deep in the shoulder and often spreads down the outer part of the upper arm. It is typically worse with use and is often worse at night, especially when lying on the affected side.
Can shoulder arthritis be treated without surgery?
Yes. For most people the first approach is non-surgical: physiotherapy to keep the shoulder moving and strengthen the muscles around it, adjusting activities that aggravate the pain, and simple pain relief or anti-inflammatory medication where your GP agrees they are safe for you.
When is it time for a shoulder replacement?
There is no fixed rule. Surgery is worth discussing when pain disturbs sleep most nights, when everyday tasks such as dressing, washing your hair or reaching a shelf have become difficult, and when non-surgical treatment no longer gives enough relief.
Why a reverse shoulder replacement?
Many people with shoulder arthritis also have a torn or worn rotator cuff. A reverse shoulder replacement does not rely on the rotator cuff to work, because it lets the deltoid muscle lift the arm. It can also correct a socket that has worn unevenly or tilted backwards, using an angled baseplate or glenosphere. Dr Mooney performs reverse total shoulder replacement, planned from a CT scan and delivered with Mako robotic assistance at Eastwood Private Hospital.
Do I have to have surgery if I see a surgeon?
No. There is no obligation to proceed with surgery at or after a consultation. Many people find value in understanding what is happening in their shoulder and what their options are, and decide on the timing themselves.
Related reading
Before surgery
Preparing for your first orthopaedic consultation →Choosing an orthopaedic surgeon in Adelaide →Prehabilitation: exercises to prepare for surgery →Am I too young (or too old) for a joint replacement? →If you are considering shoulder replacement
Robotic shoulder replacement: a first at Eastwood →How robotic assistance improves implant position →Robotic vs conventional joint replacement →Waiting times: public and private →Related conditions and procedures
Reverse shoulder replacement →Rotator cuff tear →Rotator cuff repair →Shoulder stabilisation →Discuss your shoulder pain with Dr Mooney
A specialist consultation gives you a clear picture of what is happening in your shoulder and what your options are. A GP referral is required for Medicare rebate purposes.
The information in this article is provided for general educational purposes and does not constitute medical advice. Individual circumstances vary. Please consult Dr Mooney or your GP to discuss your specific situation.